Reviewed by Ben Hill, Founder & CEO, MODLR
Comparing MODLR and Pigment means examining how each would support the planning processes in your organisation. This guide outlines documented platform features and the questions to ask about modelling, reporting, integrations, AI, implementation and ongoing costs before choosing between these two FP&A platforms.
Executive summary
MODLR and Pigment both support financial and operational planning, including budgeting, forecasting, scenario analysis, reporting, data integration and financial consolidation.
MODLR organises planning around multidimensional cubes, with Workviews for detailed analysis, Cards for dashboards and interactive interfaces, and visual processes for data preparation and automation. Pigment uses Lists, Metrics and Tables to structure planning applications, with Boards for reporting and user interaction.
This comparison examines how those approaches fit your organisation’s modelling needs, user responsibilities, controls and growth plans. It also covers implementation, ongoing maintenance, AI availability and total cost of ownership.
CFOs and FP&A teams should assess both platforms using the same requirements and representative tasks. The right choice depends on the proposed solution, the training and support your team needs, and the costs of operating and expanding it. Software evaluators should also confirm which AI functions are available in your subscription and which remain in preview or on the roadmap at decision time. .
What’s in this article
- Executive summary
- MODLR vs Pigment: An introduction
- How we compared MODLR and Pigment
- What is MODLR
- What is Pigment?
- Is MODLR a Pigment alternative?
- MODLR vs Pigment at a glance
- MODLR and Pigment detailed comparison with questions to ask
- Finance ownership and ease of use
- Modelling architecture and flexibility
- Implementation and time to value
- Forecasting and scenario planning
- Reporting and drill-down
- Data integration and Excel
- Automation and workflow
- Artificial intelligence
- Governance and auditability
- Financial close and consolidation
- Scalability and organisational fit
- Total cost of ownership
- When to consider each platform
- Questions to ask before choosing MODLR or Pigment
- MODLR vs Pigment: Key takeaway
- Do you want to know more about MODLR?
- FAQs about MODLR and Pigment
- Trademarks and copyright
MODLR vs Pigment: An introduction
When spreadsheet planning becomes difficult to coordinate, finance teams may start evaluating a shared planning platform. FP&A evaluators might prioritise connecting budgets with operational assumptions, reducing the length of planning cycles, automation of routine planning processes, managing collaboration among departments and improving the consistency of management reporting, among other business-specific considerations.
A MODLR vs Pigment evaluation should start with those requirements. A dashboard demonstration may be useful, but buyers also need to see how data is prepared and calculations are maintained. They need to understand and follow how users complete an entire planning cycle.
CFOs and FP&A teams need to define what the platform is required to do in their business, who will use it and how success will be measured. It is important to ask both vendors to demonstrate the same business processes so it becomes easier to compare and contrast.
How we compared MODLR and Pigment
This MODLR vs Pigment comparison evaluates the two platforms across the issues most relevant to CFOs and FP&A teams: modelling, ownership, implementation, forecasting, reporting, integration, automation, governance, consolidation, scalability and total cost of ownership.
Pigment capabilities are based primarily on publicly available product information and documentation available at the time of writing. MODLR capabilities are based on our knowledge of the platform as well as the official product information and documentation linked in this article.
As product capabilities, packaging, pricing and implementation requirements can change, buyers should validate their specific requirements directly with each vendor before making a purchasing decision.
What is MODLR
MODLR is a connected planning and FP&A platform built around flexible multidimensional modelling.
It brings together financial and operational data, calculations, assumptions, forecasts, scenarios, workflows and reporting within a governed planning environment.
MODLR supports areas including budgeting and forecasting, driver-based planning, scenario analysis, management reporting, financial close and consolidation, workflow, data integration, automation and Excel interaction.
MODLR provides tools for trained finance and business users to manage planning models and processes, according to their permissions and the solution’s designed for their business.
Read more: Connected Planning vs Traditional Planning: What Your Business Needs to Know
What is Pigment?
Pigment is an integrated business planning platform with enterprise performance management capabilities. It brings planning, forecasting, reporting and analysis into a shared environment across finance and other business functions.
Pigment supports FP&A and finance planning use cases, including budgeting, forecasting, variance analysis, financial reporting and headcount planning. It also extends into sales, workforce, supply chain and operational planning.
The platform is built around scalable processing, unified and governed data, and dynamic multidimensional modelling. It also provides native scenarios, reporting, granular permissions and integrations.
Pigment provides Boards for presenting planning information through grids, KPIs and charts, with views configured for different users and business requirements. They can be used to present planning information, support collaboration and provide different stakeholders with tailored views of business performance.
Is MODLR a Pigment alternative?
Yes. MODLR can be included as a Pigment alternative for financial and operational planning.
MODLR can be considered a Pigment alternative for businesses that need:
FP&A software
Budgeting and forecasting
Driver-based planning
Scenario analysis
Management reporting
Financial consolidation
Data integration
Workflow automation
Multidimensional modelling
Connected financial and operational planning
Both MODLR and Pigment platforms can replace or reduce spreadsheet-led planning and create a shared environment for finance and operational teams.
However, they do not necessarily suit the same buyer priorities. Therefore, whether MODLR is a suitable Pigment alternative depends on the specific applications, controls, integrations and commercial terms that your organisation needs.
MODLR vs Pigment at a glance
The table summarises selected tools and suggests a common evaluation test. It is not a performance ranking or an exhaustive feature inventory.
Area | MODLR | Pigment | What to verify with both |
|---|---|---|---|
Model structures | Cubes, dimensions and hierarchies | Lists, Metrics and Tables | How the model represents your business and how changes are maintained. |
Reporting tools | Workviews support detailed reporting and analysis, with Cards providing dashboards and interactive interfaces. | Boards can display grids, KPIs and charts from application data | Report design, input, filtering and the path from a result to its supporting detail. |
Scenarios | A Scenario dimension can organise actuals, budgets, forecasts and alternative plans for comparison. | Versions and Scenarios support alternative assumptions and comparisons within planning applications. | How assumptions are changed, scenarios are kept separate and connected outputs are calculated. |
Data processes | Integration tools and a Visual Process Editor for connecting, transforming and loading data, and updating models. | Connectors, scheduled imports and APIs for transferring data into and out of planning applications. | Source compatibility, data preparation, refresh frequency, maintenance and failure handling. |
Excel | Excel Add-in for reporting and working with model data from spreadsheets. | Pigment Connector for Excel for retrieving data from views and sending spreadsheet data into Pigment. | Supported Excel versions, refresh, data input, access controls and workbook maintenance . |
Consolidation | Financial Close and Consolidation solution with data loading, reconciliation, validation and audit reporting. | Financial consolidation with multi-entity and multi-currency processing, intercompany matching and eliminations, journals and reporting. | Accounting requirements, controls, configuration and included features. |
AI | Natural-language data queries, model exploration, scriptable-process assistance and Workview editing form the first-release scope. Access is being rolled out; additional functions remain on the roadmap. | Analyst and Modeler agents support analysis and model building. A Consolidation Agent supports consolidation tasks; the Planner Agent is marked as forthcoming at the review date. | Find out which functions are enabled at time of purchase and implementation, release status, permissions, charges and review controls. |
Implementation and costs | Delivery scope, timetable, responsibilities and costs are established through a tailored proposal. | Delivery scope, timetable, responsibilities and costs are established through a tailored proposal. | Equivalent deliverables, internal and external resources, dependencies and total costs over the same period |
MODLR and Pigment detailed comparison with questions to ask
The comparison between MODLR and Pigment shouldn’t be reduced to which interface looks more modern or which platform lists more features. A more useful comparison needs to focus on finding which planning architecture your business can implement, govern, operate and expand successfully.

Over the next sections we describe the following aspects of the two platforms together with questions evaluators can raise to support the comparison.
Finance ownership and ease of use
Modelling architecture and flexibility
Implementation and time to value
Forecasting and scenario planning
Reporting and drill-down
Data integration and Excel
Automation and workflow
Artificial intelligence
Governance and auditability
Financial close and consolidation
Scalability and organisational fit
Total cost of ownership
Finance ownership and ease of use
Finance ownership means being able to perform the work your team expects to manage after implementation. It may cover a wide range of aspects including the ability to change forecast assumptions, build reports, maintain calculations, minimise routine manual processes and administer access or updating of data processes.
Software evaluators must typically assess three types of usability in each platform:
Contributor usability: Can managers enter assumptions, review results and complete their assigned tasks?
Builder usability: Can trained finance users make the model and report changes you expect them to own?
Administrative usability: Can authorised staff maintain permissions, monitor processes and manage changes?
A company can test usability before implementation, but a standard demonstration may not provide hands-on access. You may want to ask for a scripted demonstration to assess ease of use before implementation. Ask both vendors to demonstrate the same planning tasks.
Where trial or evaluation access is available, invite representative users to complete selected tasks after introductory training. Record what they can do independently and where they need help. Assess contributors, model builders and administrators separately, and confirm the training and support required after implementation.
Model complexity, previous experience and corporate governance requirements typically affect the skills needed for effective use of either platform. A finance-led operating model may still require IT, vendor or partner support for particular tasks.
To find the practical difference, ask:
Which platform can our team understand, own and adapt after the implementation team leaves?
Modelling architecture and flexibility
Both Pigment and MODLR support multidimensional modelling, but organise their model data and calculations differently.
Pigment
Pigment builds planning models using connected components called Blocks, which include Dimension Lists, Transaction Lists, Metrics and Tables. Lists organise data by categories such as product, department, employee and time. Metrics hold inputs, calculations and results, while Tables bring related Metrics together for analysis and financial reporting.
Pigment’s formulas connect these components and let model builders group, allocate and filter data across different categories. This helps them model how business activities affect financial results. Building and changing models requires the appropriate permissions and an understanding of Pigment’s modelling tools and formulas.
MODLR
MODLR uses multidimensional data cubes to organise financial and operational data by categories such as entity, product, customer, department, scenario and time. Cube formulas connect calculations within and between cubes, helping users analyse results from different business perspectives. Workviews and Cards use this data for planning and reporting.
Finance teams can build models around how their business works and what they need to report. MODLR’s visual tools also help prepare, transform and load data into these models. How independently teams are able to maintain and expand them depends on complexity of models as well as training and permissions.
The practical difference
Though they have differing approaches, both support models that analyse information across multiple business dimensions.
The more useful questions to ask platforms include:
How easily can your team build, understand, maintain and adapt the model as requirements change?
Who will own the modelling process, and what training or support will they need?
How will data preparation, calculations and reporting work together?
Ask each provider to demonstrate the same practical change—for example, adding a product category, revising a workforce assumption or introducing a new profitability view. This will help you assess how each modelling approach fits your team’s skills and ongoing responsibilities.
Implementation and time to value
An implementation proposal should specify scope, responsibilities, dependencies, acceptance criteria and handover arrangements. These requirements apply to both MODLR and Pigment.
Give both vendors the same brief, including data sources, historical periods, required models, reports, workflows, users and controls. Comparing a focused first use case with a broader deployment will not provide a meaningful assessment of implementation time or effort.
You may want to request a delivery plan for a defined scope that identifies:
Design and build activities.
Data preparation and integration responsibilities.
Testing and reconciliation requirements.
User training and acceptance criteria.
Internal staff commitments.
Dependencies, exclusions and change-request arrangements.
Support during the first live planning cycle.
A phased approach can be proposed to either vendor. Ask what the first phase would deliver, what would be deferred and how later phases would connect with it. Compare the practical value, resources and dependencies of each proposal on the same basis.
Time to go-live is the period until the agreed solution is available for operational use.
Time to value is the period until an agreed, measurable benefit is achieved, such as completing a forecast cycle with less reconciliation work.
The two milestones may occur at different times. It is better to agree ahead of time how the benefit will be measured, because going live does not automatically demonstrate that it has been achieved.
Obtain estimates based on your scope and confirm the assumptions behind them.
Forecasting and scenario planning
Both MODLR and Pigment support forecasting and scenario planning, allowing teams to test assumptions, compare possible outcomes and assess how business changes could affect financial results.
Pigment
Pigment uses Versions and Scenarios to support planning and comparison. Versions organise planning cycles, such as budgets and forecasts, while Scenarios allow users to test alternative assumptions. Users can compare scenarios within Boards and Views to review how results differ.
For example, a team could test different sales volumes, prices or hiring assumptions and compare the resulting forecasts. The financial effects depend on how these assumptions connect to other parts of the model. Buyers should ask Pigment to demonstrate how scenarios work alongside forecast versions and how users can preserve a baseline for comparison.
MODLR
MODLR supports scenario planning and what-if analysis through connected financial and operational models. A Scenario dimension can hold actuals, budgets, forecasts and alternative planning assumptions within the model. Forecasts can also combine actual results for completed periods with calculated values for future periods.
Finance teams can use this structure to explore how changes in business drivers affect the outlook. For example, a change in sales volume can flow through to revenue and other linked calculations. The effect on costs, working capital and cash flow depends on the relationships included in the model. Buyers should ask MODLR to demonstrate how assumptions are changed, scenarios are compared and the resulting movements are explained.
For an explanation of how operational assumptions connect with financial forecasts, read our guide to driver-based budgeting and planning.
Example: Evaluating a revenue decline
Ask both vendors to demonstrate the same illustrative scenario: sales volume falls by 15%, prices remain unchanged, and management considers delaying selected hires.
Specify the outputs you need to review, such as revenue, gross profit, workforce costs and cash flow. If inventory, receivables or the balance sheet must also change, include those dependencies explicitly in your demonstration brief.
Assess whether users can:
Create a scenario while retaining the baseline.
Identify and document changed assumptions.
Compare results across the required periods and business units.
Trace a material movement to its drivers.
Control who can edit and approve assumptions.
Explain which outputs update and which require further modelling.
This example is an evaluation exercise, not evidence that either platform has delivered a particular result.
Explore how to frame business uncertainties and management responses in our guide to scenario planning and alternative strategies.
Reporting and drill-down
Both MODLR and Pigment provide tools for presenting planning information and investigating results. Assess how each proposed solution connects summary reports with the detail needed to explain performance.
Reporting in Pigment
Pigment uses Boards to present information through grids, KPIs, charts and other widgets. Boards can be configured for different audiences and reporting needs.
Users can expand views and investigate the data behind calculations. The detail available depends on the model, the tools configured and the user’s permissions.
Reporting in MODLR
MODLR provides Workviews for detailed model reporting and analysis, alongside Cards for dashboards and interactive interfaces.
These tools can present different views of the underlying model. Ask how the proposed management reporting solution would allow users to move from a summary figure to the relevant data and calculations, within their permissions.
Example: Investigating a margin decline
A CFO notices that forecast gross margin has fallen. Ask both vendors to demonstrate how an authorised user would investigate the same movement.
In Pigment, the investigation could start with a Board and continue through the relevant views and calculation inputs. In MODLR, it could start with a Card and continue through a Workview showing the supporting model detail.
For both solutions, request the same analysis: margin by product, customer, region or channel, with explanations of changes in prices, volumes and costs. These analyses require the relevant data and relationships to be included in the model.
For a practical approach to investigating performance movements, read our guide to month-end variance analysis.
Questions to ask
Can users move from a summary figure to supporting detail?
Can they identify the assumptions and calculations behind a movement?
Can they compare actuals, budgets, forecasts and scenarios?
Which dimensions can they use to investigate results?
Does drill-down provide model detail, source-system transactions or both?
What configuration, integrations and permissions are required?
Who can maintain reports, and what training will they need?
Use the same management reports and variance examples to assess both platforms. Confirm whether users can trace the figures, explain the movements and access the information needed for decisions.
Data integration and Excel
Both MODLR and Pigment provide tools for bringing source data into their planning environments. The integration method, preparation work and ongoing maintenance depend on your systems and the proposed solution.
FP&A teams may need data from:
ERP and accounting systems.
CRM systems.
HR and payroll systems.
Databases and data warehouses.
Operational systems.
Spreadsheets.
Pigment integrations
Pigment documents connectors and integration options for accounting, ERP, CRM, HR, data platforms and file storage. Examples include SAP, NetSuite, Sage Intacct, Salesforce, Snowflake, Google BigQuery and SFTP.
It facilitates scheduled imports, import and export APIs, and connections through third-party integration tools. The Pigment Connector for Excel supports retrieving data from Pigment views and sending spreadsheet data into the platform.
Confirm which method supports your source systems, the data you need and the required update frequency. Ask where data preparation takes place and who will maintain it.
MODLR integrations
MODLR provides integration options across accounting, ERP, CRM, HR, databases, office applications and other business systems. Examples include Xero, Salesforce, Microsoft SQL Server, SAP HANA and Google BigQuery. MODLR also has integrations for Excel, and Google Sheets.
MODLR’s visual process tools and the Visual Scripting Engine provide building blocks for database queries, API requests, files, data transformations and model updates. These can be combined into workflows for preparing and loading data.
Confirm which connections and processes are included in your proposal, what must be configured and what skills your team will need to maintain them.
Our MODLR data integration guide explains the connection methods and data preparation involved.
Confirm which connections and processes are included in your proposal, what must be configured and what skills your team will need to maintain them.
Learn how Excel can retrieve model data and submit authorised planning inputs in our guide to using the MODLR Excel Add-in.
Example: Loading monthly actuals
Ask both vendors to demonstrate the same process: load accounting actuals, map accounts and departments to the planning model, check totals and make the validated data available for reporting.
Include an exception, such as an unfamiliar account code or a failed connection. Examine how the issue is identified, who resolves it and how the load is safely completed.
Questions to ask
Can the proposed solution connect to our systems and their current versions?
Which records and fields can it transfer?
How will data be mapped, transformed and validated?
How often can data be refreshed?
Who will maintain integrations: our staff, the vendor or a partner?
Which routine changes can trained finance users make?
Are additional tools or middleware required?
How are errors identified, recorded and resolved?
What happens when source-system structures change?
What are the implementation and ongoing costs?
Compare the complete data process using the same requirements. Availability of a connector does not necessarily mean that the integration will meet your planning needs. Confirm how data will be prepared, checked, loaded and maintained in each proposed solution.
Automation and workflow
Both platforms support automation within financial and operational planning. This can include moving data, updating models and coordinating activities. The processes covered depend on the specific features included and how the solution is configured.
Automation in Pigment
Pigment supports scheduled data imports through connectors and eligible internal import configurations. Its Automations feature uses conditions in Metrics—such as a budget variance exceeding a threshold or a submission becoming ready for review—to trigger notifications or assign tasks.
These capabilities can support activities such as:
Refreshing planning data through scheduled imports.
Alerting users when a financial or operational threshold is reached.
Assigning review or approval tasks, with owners and due dates.
Linking notifications and tasks into a sequence.
Monitoring task progress and sending reminders.
Linked workflows are available for Enterprise customers, so you need to confirm their inclusion in the package proposed for your business. Workflow owners can monitor tasks and update assignees as the process progresses.
Automation in MODLR
MODLR’s Visual Process Editor lets users connect visual building blocks to create processes for handling data and maintaining planning models.
These capabilities can support activities such as:
Importing and transforming data.
Running database queries and interacting with APIs.
Reading, writing and moving files.
Updating cube data, dimensions and hierarchies.
Sending emails and handling errors and process logs.
The editor combines visual steps with options for custom processes and formulas. The skills and support required depend on the complexity of the process being built.
Questions to ask both vendors
Can you demonstrate the same process: importing actuals, checking the data, updating a forecast and notifying the person responsible for review?
Which steps are automated, and which require user action?
How are failed imports, validation errors and incomplete tasks identified and resolved?
How do users submit, approve, reject or return plans for changes? Can approved submissions be locked?
How can process owners monitor progress, send reminders and see a record of completed actions?
Who can configure and maintain these processes, and what training or technical support will they need?
Which automation and workflow features are included in the proposed package, and which require additional licences, services or external tools?
Artificial intelligence
Both platforms offer AI capabilities for working with planning data and models. Since AI capabilities are likely to keep evolving, assess the exact functions available for you at the time of assessment. These need to be separated from any features awaiting release.
Pigment AI
Pigment AI includes agents for different activities. Their Analyst Agent supports exploring metrics, identifying trends and anomalies, and producing reports. The Modeler Agent assists with model creation and changes through natural-language instructions. Consolidation Agent assists with accounting questions, reconciliation issues and consolidation controls.
Access to each depends on the relevant features and permissions enabled for users. Confirm the scope and commercial terms of each required agent.
At the time of our review (4 October 2026), the Planner Agent, to support scenario simulation and recommendations, is marked as coming soon.
MODLR AI
MODLR AI has a first-release scope covering questions about live model data in plain language, exploration of cubes, dimensions and hierarchies, assistance with scriptable processes and workview creation and editing.
MODLR notes that access is being rolled out, with a waitlist in place. Confirm which functions are enabled in your environment before including them in the evaluation.
The following capabilities remain on the roadmap as of 4 October 2026: generating Cards and charts, editing dimensions and hierarchies through AI, creating and explaining visual processes through AI, and creating structured models from uploaded attachments.
Questions to ask
Give both vendors the same tasks and assess the results.
Which AI functions can our users access today, or at the time of your intended purchase?
Which are in preview, on a waitlist or planned?
What data can the AI access?
How are user permissions applied?
Can answers from AI be checked against model data and calculations?
Does the AI suggest changes, execute them or require approval?
Can changes be reviewed and reversed?
What usage limits, charges and data-processing terms apply?
AI-generated explanations and model changes require appropriate review. Access to planning data does not, by itself, guarantee an accurate answer or a correct action.
Governance and auditability
Both platforms provide controls for managing access to planning information. You need to assess how those controls will work for you, including sensitive data, model changes and approvals.
Governance in Pigment
Pigment separates permissions and data-access rights, where permissions determine the actions users can perform and access rights determine the data users can read or change.
Roles combine these settings for different responsibilities. Separate permissions govern configuring imports, viewing model history, changing Boards and accessing AI agents.
Certain sensitive permissions enable users to expose otherwise restricted data. These should only be assigned to people who have the authority to access that information.
Governance in MODLR
MODLR provides user-management and security controls for managing access and responsibilities.
Its Financial Close and Consolidation solution includes validation rules, financial controls and audit reporting for investigating changes. Confirm which controls apply to the planning models and processes included in your proposal.
You can define who can enter data, maintain calculations, manage access and approve results. Test those responsibilities using the proposed configuration.
Questions to ask
Can access be restricted at the levels we require?
Can sensitive salary and customer information be protected?
Which administrative permissions could override those restrictions?
How are changes to a model tested and approved before the updated model is used for live planning and reporting?
Which data, formula and configuration changes are recorded?
Can we trace supporting data and calculations for reported results?
Can responsibilities be separated between preparation and approval?
How long are audit records retained, and can they be exported?
Who can maintain access settings, and what training do they need?
Which sign-in, provisioning and recovery controls are included?
To properly compare platforms, use the same access scenarios and audit requirements. Be sure to get confirmations on the controls, configuration and commercial scope in writing.
Financial close and consolidation
Financial close involves checking, reconciling and finalising accounts for a reporting period. Consolidation brings the results of multiple entities together into group financial statements after relevant currency conversions, intercompany eliminations and adjustments. Both MODLR and Pigment offer solutions in this area. Assess each against your accounting requirements, group structure and review controls.
Financial close and consolidation in Pigment
Pigment’s financial consolidation solution supports multi-entity and multi-currency consolidation, intercompany matching and eliminations, journal entries and adjustments, and consolidated financial statements. It also supports ownership structures and changes in which entities are included in the consolidation.
Close and reporting workflows help coordinate activities, while audit trails and controls support review and traceability. Pigment offers starter kits for multiple accounting frameworks, including IFRS and US GAAP. It connects consolidated actuals with planning and analysis. Confirm how the starter kit of your choice and configuration address your specific accounting policies and reporting obligations.
Financial close and consolidation in MODLR
MODLR’s Financial Close and Consolidation solution supports data loading, reconciliation, validation, audit reporting and foreign exchange analysis. Validation checks before and after data loading help identify data quality issues. Audit trails record changes to data and model structures.
Its consolidation capabilities also include multi-currency processing, intercompany matching and eliminations, journal methods and consolidated financial reporting. Rule-based processing supports financial statement consolidation, with configuration needed to reflect the organisation’s entities, accounts and consolidation requirements.
Questions to ask both vendors
Assess both platforms against your accounting requirements rather than assuming that a consolidation offering covers every statutory obligation. Prepare the same test cases for each vendor, using representative entities, currencies, ownership arrangements, intercompany balances and adjustments.
Which accounting standards and reporting requirements does the proposed solution support, and where is additional configuration required?
Can you demonstrate currency translation, intercompany matching and eliminations using our test cases?
How are ownership changes and different consolidation methods handled?
How are journals and adjustments entered, reviewed, approved and traced?
Can we reconcile consolidated results to entity submissions and trace reported figures to their underlying data?
How are validation failures, unresolved differences and incomplete reviews identified before the accounts are finalised?
How do consolidated actuals connect with management reporting and forecasting?
What happens when an adjustment is made after the close, and how are affected reports updated and reviewed?
What is supplied in the proposed package, what must be configured, and what requires additional services?
You will be better able to make an informed choice after you know the answers.
Scalability and organisational fit
Scalability is a platform’s ability to scale up by handling more data, users, calculations and planning activity while maintaining acceptable performance. It also involves keeping models, controls and administration manageable as requirements grow.
Scalability matters when an organisation:
Adds entities through acquisitions or expansion.
Plans in greater detail by product, customer, location or employee.
Retains more historical data or compares more scenarios.
Involves more people in budgeting and forecasting.
Connects additional systems or refreshes data more frequently.
Extends planning into workforce, sales or operations.
Scalability also matters during peak periods, when many users submit forecasts, calculations run and reports are refreshed at the same time.
Scalability in MODLR
MODLR uses multidimensional cubes to organise financial and operational data. Its models can cover business dimensions such as entity, product, department, time and scenario.
MODLR gives each customer a separate cloud instance—a single-tenant environment—with computing capacity that can be increased or reduced to suit their needs. Capacity planning, therefore, includes the size and number of instances required for the proposed workload.
Ask how additional data, users and planning processes would affect model design, resource requirements and costs. Confirm whether expansion requires more capacity, configuration changes or redesign.
Scalability in Pigment
Pigment uses multidimensional planning applications and its Graphite processing architecture. Its elastic engine adjusts computing resources during periods of higher demand, while parallel processing supports concurrent activity.
Ask how these capabilities would handle your expected data volumes, calculations, users and refresh cycles. You need to confirm applicable limits, commercial terms and any model changes needed as requirements grow.
Similarities and differences
Both platforms support financial and operational modelling across business dimensions. In either platform, performance depends on the proposed models, calculations, data flows and workload.
Their capacity approaches differ: MODLR provides resizable customer-specific instances, while Pigment uses an elastic processing engine. This distinction does not indicate that either platform will be faster or less expensive.
Technical capacity alone does not establish that expansion will be straightforward. Organisational fit also depends on who will maintain models, manage permissions and support additional users.
Questions to ask both vendors
Can the proposed solution handle our expected data, calculations and simultaneous users?
What happens during peak budgeting and forecasting periods?
How long do representative calculations, imports and reports take?
How closely does the test environment match the proposed live environment?
What changes are needed to add entities, users or planning processes?
Would expansion require additional capacity, licences, external tools, services or model redesign?
Who will maintain the expanded solution, and what training is required?
How will access controls and reporting consistency be maintained when scaling up?
What would expansion cost, and what are the specific cost elements involved?
You should use the same workload and growth assumptions to assess both platforms. Record demonstrated results, resource assumptions and relevant limits before drawing conclusions about scalability.
Total cost of ownership
To compare total cost of ownership with each platform, evaluators should compare current written proposals covering equivalent requirements, rather than inferring costs from vendor statements and positioning.
Follow the best practice by preparing a three-to-five-year cost model for each vendor. It will help distinguish quoted charges from your estimates of internal effort.
Cost area | What to include in the comparison |
|---|---|
Subscription | Licence charges for the required user roles, applications and computing capacity. Confirm which features and environments are included and which carry separate charges. |
Implementation | Costs for designing and building models, configuring workflows, testing results and making the solution available for use. Identify excluded work and how changes to the agreed scope will be charged. |
Integration | Costs for connecting source systems, mapping and transforming data, and validating transfers. Include any external tools or services, plus ongoing monitoring and maintenance. |
Internal effort | Time your finance, IT and business teams will spend preparing data, defining requirements, testing results and reviewing outputs. Include ongoing model ownership and administration, even where these do not create additional vendor charges. |
Training | Initial training for contributors, model builders and administrators. Include onboarding for new staff and further training as models, responsibilities or features change. |
Support | The support included in the subscription, its coverage hours and response commitments. Identify charges for additional technical assistance, model changes or help beyond the standard service. |
Growth | Costs of adding users, entities, data, environments and planning processes, including extra licences, computing capacity, middleware, data transformation tools, configuration, specialist support and ongoing maintenance. |
AI | Which AI functions are included, who can access them and what usage limits apply. Include separate subscriptions, usage credits or charges for exceeding allowances, where applicable. |
Contract and exit | Contract duration, renewal pricing, applicable taxes and cancellation terms. Include the cost and arrangements for exporting data, moving to another system and running both environments during a transition. |
Compare both proposals using the same currency, contract period and assumptions about users, data volumes and planning scope. You may want to separate one-off costs from recurring charges, and confirm how changes to these assumptions would affect the total cost.
When to consider each platform
Choosing a planning platform starts with the specific needs of your business. The following considerations can help you decide whether to include MODLR, Pigment or both in your FP&A platform shortlist.
When to consider Pigment
Consider Pigment when your evaluation includes connecting financial plans with workforce, sales or other operational plans. Examine how its Lists, Metrics and Tables would represent your business and how shared assumptions would connect the proposed applications.
Pigment’s Boards are relevant where executives, finance teams and department managers need different views of planning information. Ask vendor to demonstrate how those users would enter assumptions, compare scenarios and investigate results within their permissions.
If AI assistance is an important requirement, test the agents available in the proposed subscription on specific tasks, such as explaining a variance or helping change a model. Separate available functions from forthcoming capabilities and confirm the review controls and charges.
Where financial consolidation is required, include your entities, currencies, ownership structures and intercompany transactions in the evaluation. Confirm that you will be getting the configuration and services needed to meet your accounting requirements.
When to consider MODLR
Consider MODLR when your evaluation includes financial and operational modelling across dimensions such as product, customer, department, entity and scenario. Ask for a demonstration on how Cubes would support your calculations, profitability analysis and expected model changes.
Workviews and Cards are support both management reporting and detailed analysis. Test how they enable users to move from a summary result to supporting model data and how trained users would maintain the reports.
If recurring data preparation and model updates are priorities, assess MODLR’s visual process tools using a representative workflow. Include loading, mapping, validation and error handling, and establish which activities your team could maintain independently after training.
Where Excel remains part of planning or reporting, test the Excel Add-in against your actual workbook requirements. If consolidation is also in scope, assess the Financial Close and Consolidation solution using the same accounting test cases applied to Pigment.
Both platforms support financial and operational planning. Use these considerations to build your shortlist, then assess each proposed solution against the same business requirements.
Questions to ask before choosing MODLR or Pigment
Which processes and outputs must be delivered in the first release?
Which requirements are demonstrated, and which still need validation?
Which functions are included, configured, separately charged or planned?
Who will build, maintain and approve changes after implementation?
What training and external support will your people need?
How are integrations monitored and maintained?
How are scenarios, reports and consolidation results reconciled?
Can the proposed permissions and audit records meet our controls?
Which AI functions can we use today, and how will outputs be reviewed?
What assumptions support the implementation timetable and cost estimate?
What will operation and expansion cost over three to five years?
What contractual commitments and acceptance criteria support the proposal?
MODLR vs Pigment: Key takeaway
Both MODLR and Pigment offer financial and operational planning capabilities. The better fit for your organisation depends on how the proposed solution meets your specific requirements, who will maintain it and its total cost.
Base your choice on demonstrated capabilities and clear delivery commitments. Confirm that your team can operate and maintain the solution with the agreed levels of training and support, and within budget.
Do you want to know more about MODLR?
To find out how MODLR could support your planning and reporting requirements, contact the MODLR team.
To experience MODLR in action, request a MODLR demonstration using a representative planning or reporting requirement. Bring your data sources, expected users, reporting needs and control requirements so the discussion can address the proposed solution and its scope.
You can also:
Follow MODLR on LinkedIn for articles, product developments and FP&A insights.
Subscribe to MODLR on YouTube for demonstrations, tutorials and product updates and learn how specific capabilities work through MODLR’s demonstrations and tutorials.
Explore the latest MODLR articles and insights.
Sign up for a MODLR account to explore the platform directly: Get started with MODLR.
FAQs about MODLR and Pigment
Is MODLR a Pigment alternative?
MODLR can be evaluated alongside Pigment for financial and operational planning. Suitability depends on your organisation and the specific applications, integrations, controls and commercial terms that you require.
Is MODLR better than Pigment?
This comparison does not establish an overall winner. Evaluate each proposed solution against the same business requirements, demonstration tasks and acceptance criteria.
How do their modelling tools differ?
MODLR uses cubes, dimensions and hierarchies. Pigment uses Lists, Metrics and Tables. You may want to test how each structure supports your calculations, reporting and model maintenance.
Which platform is easier for finance to manage?
That depends on the implemented model, assigned responsibilities, training and the skills users possess. Ask your team to perform representative changes in each platform and identify where support is needed.
Which platform is faster to implement?
The length of an implementation depends on the scope of the assignment, data readiness of your organisation and the availability and access to resources. The best approach is to request delivery plans based on the same scope from both MODLR and Pigment, when data readiness, internal availability and acceptance criteria are common.
Is MODLR cheaper than Pigment?
The best way to establish affordability is to compare written proposals from both platforms with a three-to-five-year cost model covering subscriptions, delivery, internal effort, support and expansion.
Do both platforms offer consolidation?
Both MODLR and Pigment have financial consolidation offerings. Ask and confirm the included functions, configuration and services needed for your accounting and reporting requirements.
Can we continue using Excel?
MODLR has the Excel Add-in while Pigment documents an Excel connector provided as an Office Add-in. You may want to test your workbook requirements and confirm supported functionality and access conditions for each platform.
Are all advertised AI features available now?
It is better not to assume so since AI capabilities continue to evolve. MODLR’s AI page includes a waitlist and roadmap items; Pigment’s homepage marks its Planner Agent as coming soon at the review date. The best way to know what features are available is to confirm the availability and commercial terms of each required feature at the time of your evaluation.
How should we test scenario planning?
Give both vendors the same baseline, assumption changes and required outputs. Assess how scenarios are created, compared, documented and governed, and whether the results reconcile with your expected model logic.
Trademarks and copyright
MODLR and Pigment names and any associated trademarks belong to their respective owners. References to Pigment identify the platform being discussed and do not imply affiliation, sponsorship or endorsement. Copyright in linked materials remains with the respective rights holders. This article summarises those materials in original wording and does not grant permission to reproduce third-party logos, screenshots or other protected content.